BRAXTON COUNTY HISTORY
Braxton County was created by an act of the Virginia General Assembly on January 15, 1836 from parts of Lewis, Kanawha, and Nicholas counties. It was named in honor of Carter Braxton. He was a noted Virginia statesman who graduated from William and Mary College, was a long-time member of the Virginia House of Burgesses and a signer of the Declaration of Independence.

The first land survey in the county took place in 1784 on behalf of John Allison who had a warrant on 11,000 acres of land in the area. Adam O'Brien, an Indian scout and noted hunter, was part of the survey party. 7,000 acres of Allison's land were purchased by John Sutton of Alexandria, Virginia. His son, John D. Sutton, visited the area in 1798 and found a small, abandoned cabin on the land. He learned that John (or Adam) O'Brien once lived in the hollow of a large sycamore tree in the area around present day Sutton in 1773, but he never did discover who had built the cabin.

The county's first permanent English settlers were the Carpenter family, including brothers Jeremiah, Benjamin, Jesse and Amos, and their mother. They arrived in 1789 or 1790 and built a cabin at the mouth of the Holly River. Less than a year later, Benjamin Carpenter and his wife were killed by two Indians who were passing through the area. In 1800, Jeremiah and Henry Mace settled near present day Sutton. In 1807, Colonel John Haymond moved from Harrison county and settled near the Falls of the Little Kanawha. His three brothers, Benjamin, Daniel, and John Conrad, settled three miles south of him. Also in that year, Nicholas Gibson and Asa Squires moved into the county. In 1810, John D. Sutton moved to the present site of Sutton, which at the time was known as Newville.

The first meeting of the county court took place on April 11, 1836 at the home of John D. Sutton. Sutton, the county seat, had been chartered as a town by an act of the Virginia General Assembly on January 27, 1826. Originally located in Nicholas County, it had been known as Newville and later as Suttonville. The towns name was changed to Sutton on March 1, 1837 and it was incorporated on February 20, 1860.

Braxton County was the location of a famous Indian massacre. A 1764 treaty with various Indian tribes was violated in 1772 when several Indians were murdered on the South Branch of the Potomac River by Nicholas Harpold and his companions. About the same time, Bald Eagle, an Indian chief of some notoriety, was murdered while on a hunting trip on the Monongahela River. In the meantime, Captain Bull, a Delaware Indian Chief and five other Indian families were living in Braxton County an an area known as Bulltown, about 14 miles from present day Sutton. Captain Bull was regarded by most of the settlers in the region as friendly. But there were some white families who suspected Captain Bull of providing information to and harboring unfriendly Indians. While away from home in June, the family of a German immigrant named Peter Stroud was murdered, presumably by Indians. The trail left by the murderers led in the general direction of Bulltown. Peter's brother, Adam Stroud, had a cabin nearby and seeing smoke rising to the sky, raced to his brother's cabin. He gathered up what was left of the bodies and buried them. Peter then headed for Hacker's Creek where he met with several others who agreed to join him in an attack on Bulltown. They killed all of the Indians in the village and threw their bodies into a nearby river. News of Captain Bull's massacre spread across the western frontier and set off a series of incidents between the Indians and the English settlers, ending the eight years of peace on the western frontier.

Ann Bailey, an eccentric Englishwoman from Liverpool was a colorful character on the frontier and a native of Braxton County. Known as "Mad Ann", she served as a messenger for the militia during the French and Indian Wars (1754 - 1763) and was an accomplished marksman and hunter. It was said that she rode her famous black horse, Liverpool, like a man, with a rifle over one shoulder and a tomahawk and butcher's knife in her belt. She entertained many crowded campfires with the stories of her adventures and was welcomed at every home in the country.